Obamacare: The Cure That Made Insurance Sick; Washington has spent decades confusing insurance with prepaid healthcare.

The political justification sounds compassionate: Everyone deserves affordable healthcare. But compassion does not repeal arithmetic.

When insurers cannot charge premiums reflecting expected medical expenses, those expenses do not disappear. They are redistributed. Lower-risk customers subsidize higher-risk ones, regardless of whether they understand or approve of the arrangement.

There may be legitimate humanitarian reasons to assist people with expensive medical conditions. But that is a question of providing assistance, not a justification for pretending everyone represents the same insurance risk.

ObamaCare further institutionalized the confusion by requiring individual and small-group insurance policies to cover ten categories of essential health benefits, including hospitalization, maternity care, prescription drugs, preventive services, and mental health treatment.

Customers are forced to pay for services that are not only unrequested but downright irrelevant.

A sixty-year-old man has little personal use for maternity coverage. A healthy young adult might prefer an inexpensive catastrophic policy rather than comprehensive coverage with benefits he rarely expects to use.

But Washington politicians have decided that individual preferences must yield to their definition of acceptable insurance, thus forcing Americans to purchase coverage designed around political priorities rather than their own circumstances.

Comprehensive coverage and preventative medicine can be valuable. But making these services available is entirely different from compelling everyone to purchase them through insurance. There is an enormous difference between offering people protection and denying them the freedom to decide what protection they need.

When consumers purchase goods or services directly, they have reason to compare prices, evaluate alternatives, and determine whether the benefits justify the costs. But when medical expenses are routinely routed through insurance companies, these incentives fade.

Patients frequently have little idea what procedures cost. Providers negotiate reimbursement arrangements with insurance companies. The actual consumer often becomes the least informed participant in the transaction.

Nobody expects someone suffering a heart attack to shop around for the lowest-priced emergency room. Such catastrophes are precisely why insurance exists.

But routine examinations, diagnostic services, and other nonemergency medical procedures offer opportunities for transparent prices and meaningful competition.

Imagine a healthcare marketplace in which providers openly advertise prices, patients compare services, and insurance concentrates primarily on protecting against extraordinary expenses.

The resulting competition would encourage lower prices, greater efficiency, and improved service. This can be accomplished by simply restoring insurance to its original purpose.

Americans should be free to purchase genuine catastrophic medical insurance without being compelled to buy an extensive government-prescribed package of benefits.

Those wanting comprehensive coverage could purchase it. Those preferring high-deductible protection could choose that alternative. Routine expenses could be paid directly, through health savings accounts, or through voluntary subscription arrangements.

Insurance companies would compete for customers by offering coverage people actually wanted, rather than merely satisfying mandates imposed by politicians.

Premiums would more closely reflect risk, just as they do in other insurance markets.

A free-market system need not abandon those who develop expensive illnesses through no fault of their own or are unable to afford adequate coverage.

A carefully designed safety net could provide targeted assistance through publicly funded reinsurance, high-risk arrangements, or direct subsidies. 

The fundamental problem with government-directed healthcare is not just the layer of bureaucracy that injects itself between the doctors and the patients, but the presumption to know what insurance Americans must purchase, which services they must finance, and how much personal choice they must surrender.

A healthcare system should be judged by its actual consequences: affordability, accessibility, quality, innovation, and individual freedom — not the generosity of political promises.

When government mandates increasingly comprehensive coverage, it can make insurance more expensive for those who would otherwise choose less. When third-party payments replace direct purchasing, price competition weakens. When political decisions replace consumer preferences, the marketplace becomes less responsive to the people it supposedly serves.

Insurance was designed to protect people against financial risk, not relieve them of responsibility for every predictable expense of living.

A sensible system would allow Americans to select the protection they need, pay premiums that meaningfully reflect risk, and purchase routine medical services with greater control over their own money.

The choice is not between compassion and capitalism. It is between a system that acknowledges costs, respects incentives, and preserves individual choice — and one that substitutes political intentions for economic reality.

Washington has spent decades confusing insurance with prepaid healthcare. It is time to let Americans understand the difference — and choose for themselves.

Jim Cardoza is the author of The Moral Superiority of Liberty and the founder of LibertyPen.com. Read more of his essays there.

Image: U.S. Gov

Related Topics: ObamaCare, Health Care

icon
icon
icon
icon
icon
icon
icon

View & Add Comments38

About the Author

Jim Cardoza

Jim Cardoza is the author of “The Moral Superiority of Liberty” and the founder of LibertyPen.com.  Read more of his essays there.

SUPPORT AMERICAN THINKER

Now more than ever, the ability to speak our minds is crucial to the republic we cherish. If what you see on American Thinker resonates with you, please consider supporting our work with a donation of as much or as little as you can give. Every dollar contributed helps us pay our staff and keep our ideas heard and our voices strong. Thank you.https://givebutter.com/embed/c/WhA2EO?goalBar=false&gba_gb.element.id=gkx27p&gba_gb.element.platform=other

Powered by Givebutter

Advertisement

Seniors Born 1939-1969 Receive 11 Benefits This Month If They AskSuper Saving Online

Pennsylvania: Worst Car Insurance Companies for Overcharging (Is Yours On the…Comparisons | Auto Insurance

Sponsored

Advertisement

Around the web

Advertisement

Pennsylvania: Worst Car Insurance Companies for Overcharging (Is Yours On The…Auto Insurance

null

10 Strangely Useful Walmart Finds Nobody Thinks OfGiftShopDiscounts.com

COULD YOUR CHOLESTEROL BE A HIDDEN THREAT?Blood Sugar Capsules

Neurologists Beg Seniors With Neuropathy: Stop Doing This NowHealth Weekly

This Sciatica Discovery is Leaving Spine Specialists SpeechlessSmoothSpine

Surgeons: This Simple Trick Will End Knee Pain & Arthritis Quickly (Try It)Health Weekly

This Heat-Reveal Dragon Mug May Steal The Show This ChristmasYifare

Electricians: The Mistake That Doubles Your Electricity BillGadgethome

CPAP Recall Has Thousands of Sleep Apnea Sufferers Rethinking Their RoutineThe Sleep Digest

Thin Hair No More: This One Daily Vitamin is Blowing Up OnlineNoor

This Dragon Mug Has a Secret That Cold Coffee Cannot ShowHeolyge

Revcontent
icon

Trending

Advertisement

Pennsylvania: Worst Car Insurance Companies for Overcharging (Is Yours On The…Auto Insurance

This Heat-Reveal Dragon Mug May Steal The Show This ChristmasYifare

null

Thin Hair No More: This One Daily Vitamin is Blowing Up OnlineNoor

Revcontent
icon

Most ReadLast 24hrsLast 48hrsLast 7 Days

Artículo

1

The 2026 Midterms Were Compromised

Artículo

2

First Rule Of The Great Replacement: Don’t Talk About The Great Replacement

Artículo

3

And No One Stopped Them: How We Got To Now

Artículo

4

The Midterm Twilight Zone

Artículo

5

Boasberg speaks

Top ContributorsLast 7 DaysLast 30 Days

Amil Imani

Eileen F. Toplansky

Eric Utter

J.B. Shurk

Lars Møller

SponsoredX

When insurers cannot charge premiums reflecting expected medical expenses, those expenses do not disappear. They are redistributed. Lower-risk customers subsidize higher-risk ones, regardless of whether they understand or approve of the arrangement.

There may be legitimate humanitarian reasons to assist people with expensive medical conditions. But that is a question of providing assistance, not a justification for pretending everyone represents the same insurance risk.

ObamaCare further institutionalized the confusion by requiring individual and small-group insurance policies to cover ten categories of essential health benefits, including hospitalization, maternity care, prescription drugs, preventive services, and mental health treatment.

Customers are forced to pay for services that are not only unrequested but downright irrelevant.

A sixty-year-old man has little personal use for maternity coverage. A healthy young adult might prefer an inexpensive catastrophic policy rather than comprehensive coverage with benefits he rarely expects to use.

But Washington politicians have decided that individual preferences must yield to their definition of acceptable insurance, thus forcing Americans to purchase coverage designed around political priorities rather than their own circumstances.

Comprehensive coverage and preventative medicine can be valuable. But making these services available is entirely different from compelling everyone to purchase them through insurance. There is an enormous difference between offering people protection and denying them the freedom to decide what protection they need.

When consumers purchase goods or services directly, they have reason to compare prices, evaluate alternatives, and determine whether the benefits justify the costs. But when medical expenses are routinely routed through insurance companies, these incentives fade.

Patients frequently have little idea what procedures cost. Providers negotiate reimbursement arrangements with insurance companies. The actual consumer often becomes the least informed participant in the transaction.

Nobody expects someone suffering a heart attack to shop around for the lowest-priced emergency room. Such catastrophes are precisely why insurance exists.

But routine examinations, diagnostic services, and other nonemergency medical procedures offer opportunities for transparent prices and meaningful competition.

Imagine a healthcare marketplace in which providers openly advertise prices, patients compare services, and insurance concentrates primarily on protecting against extraordinary expenses.

The resulting competition would encourage lower prices, greater efficiency, and improved service. This can be accomplished by simply restoring insurance to its original purpose.

Americans should be free to purchase genuine catastrophic medical insurance without being compelled to buy an extensive government-prescribed package of benefits.

Those wanting comprehensive coverage could purchase it. Those preferring high-deductible protection could choose that alternative. Routine expenses could be paid directly, through health savings accounts, or through voluntary subscription arrangements.

Insurance companies would compete for customers by offering coverage people actually wanted, rather than merely satisfying mandates imposed by politicians.

Premiums would more closely reflect risk, just as they do in other insurance markets.

A free-market system need not abandon those who develop expensive illnesses through no fault of their own or are unable to afford adequate coverage.

A carefully designed safety net could provide targeted assistance through publicly funded reinsurance, high-risk arrangements, or direct subsidies. 

The fundamental problem with government-directed healthcare is not just the layer of bureaucracy that injects itself between the doctors and the patients, but the presumption to know what insurance Americans must purchase, which services they must finance, and how much personal choice they must surrender.

A healthcare system should be judged by its actual consequences: affordability, accessibility, quality, innovation, and individual freedom — not the generosity of political promises.

When government mandates increasingly comprehensive coverage, it can make insurance more expensive for those who would otherwise choose less. When third-party payments replace direct purchasing, price competition weakens. When political decisions replace consumer preferences, the marketplace becomes less responsive to the people it supposedly serves.

Insurance was designed to protect people against financial risk, not relieve them of responsibility for every predictable expense of living.

A sensible system would allow Americans to select the protection they need, pay premiums that meaningfully reflect risk, and purchase routine medical services with greater control over their own money.

The choice is not between compassion and capitalism. It is between a system that acknowledges costs, respects incentives, and preserves individual choice — and one that substitutes political intentions for economic reality.

Washington has spent decades confusing insurance with prepaid healthcare. It is time to let Americans understand the difference — and choose for themselves.

Jim Cardoza is the author of The Moral Superiority of Liberty and the founder of LibertyPen.com. Read more of his essays there.

Image: U.S. Gov

Related Topics: ObamaCare, Health Care

icon
icon
icon
icon
icon
icon
icon

View & Add Comments38

About the Author

Jim Cardoza

Jim Cardoza is the author of “The Moral Superiority of Liberty” and the founder of LibertyPen.com.  Read more of his essays there.

SUPPORT AMERICAN THINKER

Now more than ever, the ability to speak our minds is crucial to the republic we cherish. If what you see on American Thinker resonates with you, please consider supporting our work with a donation of as much or as little as you can give. Every dollar contributed helps us pay our staff and keep our ideas heard and our voices strong. Thank you.https://givebutter.com/embed/c/WhA2EO?goalBar=false&gba_gb.element.id=gkx27p&gba_gb.element.platform=other

Powered by Givebutter

Advertisement

Seniors Born 1939-1969 Receive 11 Benefits This Month If They AskSuper Saving Online

Pennsylvania: Worst Car Insurance Companies for Overcharging (Is Yours On the…Comparisons | Auto Insurance

Sponsored

Advertisement

Around the web

Advertisement

Pennsylvania: Worst Car Insurance Companies for Overcharging (Is Yours On The…Auto Insurance

null

10 Strangely Useful Walmart Finds Nobody Thinks OfGiftShopDiscounts.com

COULD YOUR CHOLESTEROL BE A HIDDEN THREAT?Blood Sugar Capsules

Neurologists Beg Seniors With Neuropathy: Stop Doing This NowHealth Weekly

This Sciatica Discovery is Leaving Spine Specialists SpeechlessSmoothSpine

Surgeons: This Simple Trick Will End Knee Pain & Arthritis Quickly (Try It)Health Weekly

This Heat-Reveal Dragon Mug May Steal The Show This ChristmasYifare

Electricians: The Mistake That Doubles Your Electricity BillGadgethome

CPAP Recall Has Thousands of Sleep Apnea Sufferers Rethinking Their RoutineThe Sleep Digest

Thin Hair No More: This One Daily Vitamin is Blowing Up OnlineNoor

This Dragon Mug Has a Secret That Cold Coffee Cannot ShowHeolyge

Revcontent
icon

Trending

Advertisement

Pennsylvania: Worst Car Insurance Companies for Overcharging (Is Yours On The…Auto Insurance

This Heat-Reveal Dragon Mug May Steal The Show This ChristmasYifare

null

Thin Hair No More: This One Daily Vitamin is Blowing Up OnlineNoor

Revcontent
icon

Most ReadLast 24hrsLast 48hrsLast 7 Days

Artículo

1

The 2026 Midterms Were Compromised

Artículo

2

First Rule Of The Great Replacement: Don’t Talk About The Great Replacement

Artículo

3

And No One Stopped Them: How We Got To Now

Artículo

4

The Midterm Twilight Zone

Artículo

5

Boasberg speaks

Top ContributorsLast 7 DaysLast 30 Days

Amil Imani

Eileen F. Toplansky

Eric Utter

J.B. Shurk

Lars Møller

SponsoredX

Insurance used to be a relatively straightforward proposition. People voluntarily pooled their money to protect themselves against financial disasters that might otherwise ruin them. Homeowners purchased insurance against fires, motorists against accidents, and families against catastrophic medical expenses. Because millions contributed to the pool, sufficient funds were available to compensate the unfortunate few who suffered serious losses.

It was an ingenious arrangement based upon a simple recognition: risk can be shared, but it cannot be abolished.

Then came the politicians.

Dissatisfied with health insurance merely protecting people against financial catastrophe, Washington decided it should be reinvented as a prepaid medical plan that also paid for ordinary, predictable expenses. That was the origin of ObamaCare. Since then, Americans have been unduly fleeced by a program grossly misnamed the Affordable Care Act.

When Washington unveiled ObamaCare, Americans were promised a more affordable healthcare system. Sixteen years later, the numbers tell a rather inconvenient story. According to the Kaiser Family Foundation, average annual employer-sponsored family health insurance premiums have soared from $13,770 in 2010 to approximately $28,303 in 2026 — an increase of more than 105 percent. That’s an additional $14,533 annually, or more than $1,200 per month, in total insurance costs. And that doesn’t include the deductibles, copayments, and other expenses families encounter when they actually seek medical care. This result was predictable from the outset.

Consider automobile insurance. Motorists purchase protection against accidents, theft, and liability. But nobody expects an automobile insurer to pay for oil changes, tire rotations, or routine tune-ups. These are predictable expenses associated with owning a vehicle, not unforeseen catastrophes.

Imagine Congress passing the Affordable Automobile Act, requiring every insurance policy to cover oil changes, car washes, replacement tires, and windshield wipers. Politicians would undoubtedly congratulate themselves for making automobile maintenance more affordable. Except they wouldn’t have.

The costs would simply be incorporated into premiums, along with the additional expense of processing claims, negotiating reimbursements, and administering government requirements. What motorists previously purchased directly would now be purchased through an expensive intermediary.

And because these services appeared to be covered by insurance, consumers would have less incentive to compare prices or question costs. Politicians might call this progress, but economists would identify it as stupidity.

Insurance was designed to protect against financial catastrophe, not to transform every expense into an insurance claim.

Another fundamental principle of insurance is that premiums should reflect risk. A motorist with twenty accident-free years represents a different risk than someone who has totaled three automobiles in eighteen months. Consequently, insurers charge different premiums. Nobody seriously expects the safer driver to subsidize the reckless one indefinitely.

Yet when it comes to health insurance, politicians have increasingly insisted that premiums be divorced from individual medical risk.

Under ObamaCare, insurers generally cannot adjust individual-market premiums according to medical history or health status. Premium differences are largely restricted to age, geography, tobacco use, family size, and plan category.

The political justification sounds compassionate: Everyone deserves affordable healthcare. But compassion does not repeal arithmetic.

When insurers cannot charge premiums reflecting expected medical expenses, those expenses do not disappear. They are redistributed. Lower-risk customers subsidize higher-risk ones, regardless of whether they understand or approve of the arrangement.

There may be legitimate humanitarian reasons to assist people with expensive medical conditions. But that is a question of providing assistance, not a justification for pretending everyone represents the same insurance risk.

ObamaCare further institutionalized the confusion by requiring individual and small-group insurance policies to cover ten categories of essential health benefits, including hospitalization, maternity care, prescription drugs, preventive services, and mental health treatment.

Customers are forced to pay for services that are not only unrequested but downright irrelevant.

A sixty-year-old man has little personal use for maternity coverage. A healthy young adult might prefer an inexpensive catastrophic policy rather than comprehensive coverage with benefits he rarely expects to use.

But Washington politicians have decided that individual preferences must yield to their definition of acceptable insurance, thus forcing Americans to purchase coverage designed around political priorities rather than their own circumstances.

Comprehensive coverage and preventative medicine can be valuable. But making these services available is entirely different from compelling everyone to purchase them through insurance. There is an enormous difference between offering people protection and denying them the freedom to decide what protection they need.

When consumers purchase goods or services directly, they have reason to compare prices, evaluate alternatives, and determine whether the benefits justify the costs. But when medical expenses are routinely routed through insurance companies, these incentives fade.

Patients frequently have little idea what procedures cost. Providers negotiate reimbursement arrangements with insurance companies. The actual consumer often becomes the least informed participant in the transaction.

Nobody expects someone suffering a heart attack to shop around for the lowest-priced emergency room. Such catastrophes are precisely why insurance exists.

But routine examinations, diagnostic services, and other nonemergency medical procedures offer opportunities for transparent prices and meaningful competition.

Imagine a healthcare marketplace in which providers openly advertise prices, patients compare services, and insurance concentrates primarily on protecting against extraordinary expenses.

The resulting competition would encourage lower prices, greater efficiency, and improved service. This can be accomplished by simply restoring insurance to its original purpose.

Americans should be free to purchase genuine catastrophic medical insurance without being compelled to buy an extensive government-prescribed package of benefits.

Those wanting comprehensive coverage could purchase it. Those preferring high-deductible protection could choose that alternative. Routine expenses could be paid directly, through health savings accounts, or through voluntary subscription arrangements.

Insurance companies would compete for customers by offering coverage people actually wanted, rather than merely satisfying mandates imposed by politicians.

Premiums would more closely reflect risk, just as they do in other insurance markets.

A free-market system need not abandon those who develop expensive illnesses through no fault of their own or are unable to afford adequate coverage.

A carefully designed safety net could provide targeted assistance through publicly funded reinsurance, high-risk arrangements, or direct subsidies. 

The fundamental problem with government-directed healthcare is not just the layer of bureaucracy that injects itself between the doctors and the patients, but the presumption to know what insurance Americans must purchase, which services they must finance, and how much personal choice they must surrender.

A healthcare system should be judged by its actual consequences: affordability, accessibility, quality, innovation, and individual freedom — not the generosity of political promises.

When government mandates increasingly comprehensive coverage, it can make insurance more expensive for those who would otherwise choose less. When third-party payments replace direct purchasing, price competition weakens. When political decisions replace consumer preferences, the marketplace becomes less responsive to the people it supposedly serves.

Insurance was designed to protect people against financial risk, not relieve them of responsibility for every predictable expense of living.

A sensible system would allow Americans to select the protection they need, pay premiums that meaningfully reflect risk, and purchase routine medical services with greater control over their own money.

The choice is not between compassion and capitalism. It is between a system that acknowledges costs, respects incentives, and preserves individual choice — and one that substitutes political intentions for economic reality.

Washington has spent decades confusing insurance with prepaid healthcare. It is time to let Americans understand the difference — and choose for themselves.

Jim Cardoza is the author of The Moral Superiority of Liberty and the founder of LibertyPen.com. Read more of his essays there.

Image: U.S. Gov

Related Topics: ObamaCare, Health Care

icon
icon
icon
icon
icon
icon
icon

View & Add Comments38

About the Author

Jim Cardoza

Jim Cardoza is the author of “The Moral Superiority of Liberty” and the founder of LibertyPen.com.  Read more of his essays there.

SUPPORT AMERICAN THINKER

Now more than ever, the ability to speak our minds is crucial to the republic we cherish. If what you see on American Thinker resonates with you, please consider supporting our work with a donation of as much or as little as you can give. Every dollar contributed helps us pay our staff and keep our ideas heard and our voices strong. Thank you.https://givebutter.com/embed/c/WhA2EO?goalBar=false&gba_gb.element.id=gkx27p&gba_gb.element.platform=other

Powered by Givebutter

Advertisement

Seniors Born 1939-1969 Receive 11 Benefits This Month If They AskSuper Saving Online

Pennsylvania: Worst Car Insurance Companies for Overcharging (Is Yours On the…Comparisons | Auto Insurance

Sponsored

Advertisement

Around the web

Advertisement

Pennsylvania: Worst Car Insurance Companies for Overcharging (Is Yours On The…Auto Insurance

null

10 Strangely Useful Walmart Finds Nobody Thinks OfGiftShopDiscounts.com

COULD YOUR CHOLESTEROL BE A HIDDEN THREAT?Blood Sugar Capsules

Neurologists Beg Seniors With Neuropathy: Stop Doing This NowHealth Weekly

This Sciatica Discovery is Leaving Spine Specialists SpeechlessSmoothSpine

Surgeons: This Simple Trick Will End Knee Pain & Arthritis Quickly (Try It)Health Weekly

This Heat-Reveal Dragon Mug May Steal The Show This ChristmasYifare

Electricians: The Mistake That Doubles Your Electricity BillGadgethome

CPAP Recall Has Thousands of Sleep Apnea Sufferers Rethinking Their RoutineThe Sleep Digest

Thin Hair No More: This One Daily Vitamin is Blowing Up OnlineNoor

This Dragon Mug Has a Secret That Cold Coffee Cannot ShowHeolyge

Revcontent
icon

Trending

Advertisement

Pennsylvania: Worst Car Insurance Companies for Overcharging (Is Yours On The…Auto Insurance

This Heat-Reveal Dragon Mug May Steal The Show This ChristmasYifare

null

Thin Hair No More: This One Daily Vitamin is Blowing Up OnlineNoor

Revcontent
icon

Most ReadLast 24hrsLast 48hrsLast 7 Days

Artículo

1

The 2026 Midterms Were Compromised

Artículo

2

First Rule Of The Great Replacement: Don’t Talk About The Great Replacement

Artículo

3

And No One Stopped Them: How We Got To Now

Artículo

4

The Midterm Twilight Zone

Artículo

5

Boasberg speaks

Top ContributorsLast 7 DaysLast 30 Days

Amil Imani

Eileen F. Toplansky

Eric Utter

J.B. Shurk

Lars Møller

SponsoredX

Rubio leads Vance by 20 points in ‘28 Republican primary poll

Vice President J.D. Vance, who has often led early polls of the 2028 Republican field, now trails Secretary of State Marco Rubio 44% to 24% in a new Emerson College survey.

The poll surfaces just as Mr. Vance faces criticism from fellow Republicans over his comments on the Iran war and his removal by President Trump from diplomacy talks with Iran.

The Washington Times reached out to Mr. Vance’s office for comment.

According to the survey, 44% of Republican primary voters who responded to the survey chose Mr. Rubio from a list that included Mr. Vance at 24%, Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis at 9%, Donald Trump Jr. at 6% and online video podcaster Tucker Carlson at 5%.

When presented with an open-ended Republican Primary scenario, 36% of respondents chose Mr. Rubio, 20% opted for Mr. Vance, and 7% each selected Mr. DeSantis, Rep. Thomas Massie of Kentucky and Mr. Trump, despite his ineligibility to run for a third term.

Mr. Vance has often led Mr. Rubio in such polls. Just last month, a New York Times/Siena University poll showed Mr. Vance with 33%, leading second-place Mr. Rubio by ten points in a potential Republican presidential field.

The Emerson poll comes just as Mr. Vance is facing scrutiny among Republicans for online comments he made about blaming the Iran war as the reason he thought Republicans suffered heavy losses in the midterm elections. They lost both chambers of Congress, several governorships and state legislatures.

Kerry Pickett, The Washington Times

Where Does Self-Esteem Come From?

If you think about it, self-esteem doesn’t just consist of confidence in YOUR OWN mind. Self-esteem also consists of confidence in THE HUMAN MIND. If you aren’t convinced of the power of human reasoning, then of what value is your own mind and brain? Today’s collapse of reason in ethics, government, culture, sports, entertainment, families, marriages, and schools contributes to a chronically anxiety-provoking sense within people that “If the world is this mad, then how can I cope with it all?” Or, “If nobody can be counted on to think and act rationally, then how can I be expected to think critically — and why should I even try?”

Confidence in human reason fuels confidence in one’s own capacity to think and act intelligently in life. And using your own intelligence fuels confidence in your hope for human potential and the human race.

Michael J. Hurd, Daily Dose of Reason

The Art of Thinking

People ask me all the time, “So what’s better? Psychiatric drugs or talk therapy?” Over the last 26 years, regular visitors to this page have been reading that ideas and thoughts are the cause of emotions and actions, and that psychiatric drugs cannot be the primary tool for correcting negative thoughts. At best, they might help to “even out” emotional instability while the client works to correct misguided ideas.

Interestingly, when meds and talk therapy are combined, it’s difficult to determine which contributes more to the subject’s improvement. Many years ago, a client told me, “It’s better to swim with the current than against the current. Psychiatric medication might help me swim with the current, but if I’m going to get anywhere, I still have to swim.” And therein lies the key: Medication is secondary, and the mind must continue to think and function in order for flawed ideas to be changed. Indeed, with or without drugs, I still work in partnership with my clients to correct misguided and false ideas.

Sadly, medication is often prescribed in an effort to bypass that process. A psychiatrist might spend five minutes with a patient, decide the patient is depressed, and prescribe medication. Often, the doctor doesn’t talk with the patient about his or her problems, and might not even refer the patient to a psychotherapist who can get a better idea of what’s going on. This conveys to the patient the false idea that medication is the first and only option.

If, in fact, drugs do “even out” emotional instability while the person takes responsibility for thinking, then the medical path is all well and good. But in over 40 years of professional counseling, very few people have ever told me that their medication helps, and more have said that it either doesn’t help or that it makes things worse.

Unfortunately, all of this can lead the patient to believe that he has no responsibility for his mental functioning, and therefore no control over it; thus triggering a vicious cycle of more anxiety and/or depression. If someone simply told him that medication is, at best, a way to calm him so he can think more effectively, he would be a lot better off.

I’m not against anything — medication or whatever — that objectively helps. What I am against is the idea of biological determinism, i.e., that biology is destiny, that genetics and brain physiology determine everything about a person. If this were true, a doctor could just prescribe medication for everything; pretending that the patient’s attitudes and behaviors have nothing to do with how she feels. That sense of helplessness would be more depressing and anxiety-provoking than anything the patient was probably thinking in the first place.

People sometimes tell me, “I’m taking these pills and I’m doing better. But I’m not sure if it’s the medicine or the counseling that’s helping. Or, maybe I’m better because the problem got better.”

Psychiatric medications rarely, if ever, clear up or truly cure emotional problems the way antibiotics heal infections or a cast helps to mend a broken leg. In fact, I haven’t seen a single example of that. There are just too many variables that impact a person’s emotional situation.

The most important factors affecting a person’s psychological state are ideas, beliefs and the actions one takes as a result of those beliefs. When all is said and done, my advice regarding medication is to take it if it helps. And, by “help,” I mean that it makes it easier to do what you ultimately need to do: To think, introspect and use your mind to reason things out – with or without a therapist. My client so many years ago said it best: “…if I’m going to get anywhere, I still have to swim.”

Michael J. Hurd, Life’s a Beach

THE 2026 MIDTERMS WERE COMPROMISED

Autism article image
icon
icon
icon
icon
icon
icon
icon
icon

The November 2026 midterms did not deliver clean results. They delivered a cascade of red flags that any honest observer must confront. This left many Americans questioning whether the results truly reflected the will of the voters. Federal data, documented cases, Election Day failures, mail-in anomalies, and viral evidence of irregularities form a pattern that cannot be dismissed as isolated human error. Federal agencies themselves documented the scale of the problem. The Department of Homeland Security reported more than 1,600 active voter fraud investigations, over 150 arrests, and roughly 300,000 suspicious records under review in the run-up to the election. A million-dollar reward was offered for tips. These are not the statistics of a secure system. They are the statistics of a system under siege.

The Heritage Foundation’s database of proven election fraud cases — more than 1,500 documented instances and over 1,300 criminal convictions — shows this is not a new phenomenon. It is a long-standing vulnerability that federal authorities were still racing to contain as voters went to the polls. When hundreds of thousands of records are flagged through cross-checks of voter rolls, immigration data, and state files, the claim that “nothing is happening” collapses. An automated flag is not yet a conviction, but 1,620 formal inquiries nationwide is not clerical noise. It is a warning.

Election Day itself exposed the machinery’s fragility at the worst possible moments. In Westchester County, New York, during the razor-thin congressional race between Mike Lawler and Cait Conley, optical scanners suddenly stopped accepting Election Day ballots. Republicans vote heavily on Election Day. The machines failed precisely when those ballots were being cast. Officials blamed a programming update that created a formatting mismatch with the printed ballots. Voters were told to drop their paper into emergency compartments. The optics were disastrous: in a competitive district, the very systems designed to count votes rejected the votes of one side’s strongest turnout method. Similar failures and “glitches” appeared elsewhere. Videos from multiple states captured touchscreens flipping candidate selections when voters tapped them. Capacitive screens can lose calibration. Knuckles can brush edges. But the pattern of these failures occurring in high-stakes races is what demands explanation, not dismissal.

ChatGPT

The software behind these machines compounds the distrust. Companies run proprietary code that the public cannot inspect. Rumors of vendor influence, remote access capabilities, and past controversies refuse to die. Officials insist the machines are air-gapped and subjected to Logic and Accuracy tests. They insist post-election audits of paper batches provide the final check. Yet when the same systems produce sudden rejections and screen flips at critical moments, confidence evaporates. Software can be tested. It can also be compromised. The public is asked to trust black-box systems whose vendors have faced years of suspicion.

Mail-in voting supplied the most dramatic shifts. Across California and multiple swing states, candidates who led on Election Night watched their leads disappear as batch after batch of mail-in ballots arrived over subsequent days and nights. The so-called “blue shift” is presented as a natural result of processing rules that delay the opening and scanning of mail ballots. Signature verification takes time. Flattening and review take time. But the consistent directional effect — late ballots moving races in one direction — creates the appearance of a system that can be gamed by volume and timing. Viral video from Ventura County showed mail-in envelopes punched with two holes. Critics correctly noted that those holes could allow workers to see how ballots were marked and selectively discard them. Officials offered explanations about tactile orientation for the visually impaired and empty-envelope checks. The public saw a process that invited abuse.

Concentrated registrations at commercial mail facilities have long been a red flag for fraud investigators. Ballot harvesting — paid operatives collecting stacks of mail ballots from nursing homes, apartment complexes, and other high-density locations – remains legal in too many jurisdictions. Unique barcodes and signature matching are cited as safeguards. Those safeguards still leave room for pressure, coercion, and selective delivery of harvested ballots into drop boxes.

Online platforms and comment sections are filled with firsthand accounts from poll watchers, statistical charts showing suspiciously uniform shift bands, and reports of major seizures, including claims of an FBI raid on a Houston warehouse containing 20,000 fake ballots. Courts demand physical evidence under oath and reject volumes of online reports as insufficient. That legal standard protects against frivolous challenges. It also leaves unresolved the widespread perception — fueled by federal investigation numbers, machine failures timed to Election Day voting, late-night ballot dumps, and registration anomalies – that the system failed to deliver transparent, trustworthy results.

Administrative friction is real. Printers jam. Programming updates fail. Mail processing stretches for days. Those are not imaginary problems. They are the exact points of vulnerability that allow errors – or worse – to affect outcomes. When the same friction repeatedly disadvantages one side’s preferred voting method, when federal agencies are investigating thousands of cases while offering cash rewards for tips, and when the public watches leads evaporate under late mail-in batches, the conclusion is unavoidable: the 2026 midterms were compromised. The safeguards that exist on paper did not prevent the patterns that now define the election. Americans who demand cleaner elections are not conspiracy theorists. They are citizens who can add.

Amil Imani, American Thinker

Trump Meets With Ruthless Dictators To Prepare For Dealing With Democrat-Controlled Congress

SHENZHEN — President Donald Trump met with two murderous dictators this week to prepare himself for having to deal with a Democrat-controlled Congress.

White House officials described the summit as a training exercise designed to gradually rebuild the president’s tolerance for threats and politically motivated investigations before the new Congress starts in January.

“These are vicious people. They want total control. They’ll destroy anyone who gets in their way,” Trump told reporters. “But I don’t have to meet with them until next year. Today, it’s just Vladimir and Xi. They’re easier than the Democrats, if you can believe it.”

According to Trump, the summit had served as excellent preparation. “Vladimir made some very nasty threats. Excellent threats. I’m getting so much practice under my belt,” Trump said. “They’re not Democrat-level threats, but he’s getting better. No one’s shot at me yet, so we still have some work to do.”

President Xi also participated by threatening to throw Trump in prison, but neglected to say it was to protect democracy. Trump reportedly made him start the whole thing over from the beginning.

At publishing time, after understanding the reasoning for the summit, Xi and Putin had both offered Trump political asylum.

Babylon Bee

After Crippling Crimea Bridge, Ukraine Attacks It Again.  Russia has vowed to quickly restore the structure, but engineering specialists say the work could take years.

Ukraine has again attacked the only bridge linking mainland Russia with Crimea, Russian officials said on Thursday, two days after an elaborate Ukrainian assault knocked out the structure’s main four-lane roadway.

The latest attack came hours after a Russian transportation minister said the bridge would be restored “within a tight time frame.” Engineering specialists say the work is likely to take years.

The extent of the new damage to the bridge, which is both symbolically and logistically important to Moscow, was unclear. Russian officials said that rail service across the bridge had been suspended after the latest strikes. Sergei Aksyonov, the Russia-installed head of occupied Crimea, said that train service was expected to resume late on Thursday afternoon.

The steel arch that crashed into the sea early Tuesday after a Ukrainian drone and missile attack was the most complex element of the structure, known as the Kerch Strait Bridge. Perched over a shipping channel, the nearly 750-foot-long arch was installed in October 2017 three years after Russia illegally annexed Crimea. The arch elevated the roadway more than 100 feet above the channel so cargo ships and other vessels could pass between the Black Sea and the Sea of Azov.

The $4 billion bridge is a symbol of what Russia calls its “irreversible” control over Crimea. More broadly, it is a monument to Mr. Putin’s ambitions.

Ivan Nechepurenko

The Importance of Philosophy in Human Life

At the very mention of the word “philosophy,” most people tune out and head for the intellectual and psychological equivalent of the hills. But philosophy involves our most fundamental thinking about literally everything: our minds, our purpose in life, how and why we should do what we do. There’s no escaping it. And philosophy is not the same thing as religion.

Some years back, a loyal reader (a journalist and writer himself), Joseph Kellard, did this interview with me. Many Daily Dose of Reason fans have never seen it. Enjoy!

Mr. Kellard: Since modern philosophers have made a mockery of philosophy and thus destroyed its connection and importance to life, do you think that most people are ignorant of the fact that a healthier mind is rooted in understanding and correcting their fundamental philosophic ideas; that one’s psychology is a derivative of one’s philosophy?

Dr. Hurd: Absolutely. Most people think philosophy is a bunch of nonsense—and, given what they are offered by modern philosophers (from Immanuel Kant onward) as well as conventional religion—who can blame them?

Some people do understand, or at least sense, that their emotional states have something to do with their underlying ideas, but such people are, in my experience, few and far between.

The great majority of people I encounter, as a mental health professional, approach therapy with the assumption that therapy is a passive process in which something is “done to” them (like surgery, or medical treatment) as opposed to an active process of identifying mistaken ideas and behaviors. They often react with surprise and even resentment when they learn that they are responsible for their emotional states, and that they have to work on changing their emotions by changing their underlying premises and their behaviors. Some recover from this realization quickly, and are subsequently able to make progress in therapy.

Mr. Kellard: Philosopher Leonard Peikoff has said that psychology is in a pre-scientific state. He compares Sigmund Freud to Plato, in that Plato raised all the right questions in philosophy but gave all the wrong answers. Aristotle, Plato’s student, provided the right answers. Similarly, Freud raised the right questions in psychology but gave the wrong answers; however, there has been no Aristotle in psychology yet. What do you think of this analogy? And do you think Objectivism, Ayn Rand’s philosophy, has contributed to any valid ideas in psychology, or developed any better or new rational paths for it?

Dr. Hurd: I agree with the analogy between Freud and Plato. Freud’s main contribution is that he established a scientific basis for emotions and consciousness which had previously been the domain of religion and mysticism. Unfortunately, he also advanced the idea that man is nothing more than an instinctual beast torn by essentially incurable internal conflicts. In some respects, this is worse than religion, because it eliminates all possibility of man developing a moral code, including a rational one. If man is a hopeless animal, after all, then what’s the point of identifying a proper morality?

Objectivism provides the base for a rational psychology. First of all, it provides a rational moral code, a code which (unlike that offered by religion) actually works, is actually life-enhancing rather than life-destroying.

A multitude of psychological problems are caused by the dominant Judeo-Christian ethic that sacrifice is the good, rather than rational self-interest, productivity, and happiness. Secondly, Objectivism provides a rational epistemology, reason, and identifies the fact that emotions are simply automatic consequences of one’s underlying ideas, values, and premises. Studying Objectivism and—more importantly, psychologically speaking—internalizing, automatizing, and integrating Objectivism into day-to-day life represents an enormous step forward into psychological health.

Of course, the specific methods of resolving emotional problems are to be found in the fields of psychology and psychotherapy, rather than philosophy. For instance, cognitive-behavioral therapy (which I practice) helps a person identify the premises implicit in his emotions/behaviors and to correct and challenge them, where necessary.

To the best of my knowledge, the innovators of cognitive-behavioral therapy (such as Aaron Beck and David Burns, both psychiatrists) were not students of Objectivism, nor were they influenced by it, but Objectivism nevertheless provides the philosophical basis for this technique. By “philosophical basis” I mean the idea that emotional states are a consequence of one’s underlying ideas, thoughts, and premises.

Mr. Kellard: What advantage does an individual who generally understands and consistently practices Objectivism have in overcoming psychological problems, such as unearned guilt or unwarranted fears, compared to a person who just passively follows a hodgepodge of contradictory fundamental ideas, such as those offered by religion, skepticism, pragmatism?

Dr. Hurd: A serious Objectivist will usually approach therapy with more realistic and accurate expectations. He understands the nature of man and the proper code by which a man should live. He is at an enormous advantage compared to, say, the religious altruist, who thinks he is a bad person if he does not sacrifice, or the cynical pragmatist, who does not think anything and usually just wants a quick-fix to get rid of his problems with little or no work.

The mistake many Objectivists make, in my experience, is that they feel guilty for their mistaken emotions, as if they somehow had a mistaken emotion on purpose. For example, an individual might feel morally guilty or bad simply because he had an altruistic or mystical emotion. He needs to understand that emotions do not have the metaphysical status of actions. Emotions can be mistaken, or illogical, and in need of correction. But emotions, as such, cannot be “bad” or “good” the way actions can. Internalizing and automatizing rational ideas, in the context of a society where the dominant philosophic ideas are overwhelmingly irrational, is no easy task.

Psychological health, like liberty, requires eternal vigilance.

Mr. Kellard: In an article entitled “Self-Esteem Requires Work Not Words,” in your Living Resources Newsletter, you wrote that the political conservatives’ alternative for greater self-esteem is generally embodied in the following premise: “We need to stop being so selfish, and return to obedience to God, family and nation.”

With the rise over the past thirty years in illiteracy, drug use and crime, to name just a few American ills, one could assert with plausibility that the “good old days” were better in these respects. Are these ills caused primarily by the erosion of the better elements that people once practiced more consistently, such as rationality and self-interest—which develop authentic self-esteem—and that the elements conservatives now uphold as remedial, namely religion and family values, actually contributed to these and similar ills?

Dr. Hurd: For the most part, the ideas of the good old days rested on the same premises as the modern ideas. The old days necessarily had to lead to today’s mess. For instance, people used to be taught that selfishness is evil, that sacrifice is good, and that therefore you should always give to others without expecting to receive. This is such a stupid, foolish idea that sooner or later people have to rebel against it. And today that is exactly what is happening. Going on the same identical premise, that sacrifice is the good, people today simply have turned the tables: instead of sacrificing for others, they demand that others sacrifice for them. Notice that in both cases sacrifice is the rationalization and alleged justification. It’s as if the majority of people are now saying to themselves, “It’s my turn. I’m not going to sacrifice myself to others, like my parents did. I’m going to make others sacrifice for me.” Of course, nobody is this explicit about it, but this premise nevertheless underlies many of today’s cultural trends.

Superficially, the good old days were certainly better, in that there was less crime and drug abuse and so forth. However, once you understand that the premise of sacrifice, grounded in anti-reason and anti-reality, had to lead to today’s mess, you’re not so inclined to turn back the clock.

Mr. Kellard: Since the person who mistreats or “uses” people, or who cheats, defrauds or lies to them to gain his values is generally called “selfish,” can you explain in psychological terms why such a person is actually not acting selfishly but is instead sacrificing others to himself and therefore acting with profound self-disregard?

Dr. Hurd: Such a person is at war with reality. By definition, he is living short-range. He has no long-range goals and as a consequence his life has no purpose, no direction, and he will never feel the natural “high” that comes from achieving one’s long term goals and values over time. It is no accident that many people with these psychological/moral problems are also drug or alcohol abusers. Since they will never attain the natural “highs,” they desperately reach out for anything they can find.

Have you ever achieved a long-term goal of value to you? A college degree? The successful completion of a business or artistic project? A happy relationship which actually works? If you have, then imagine your life without any of these things, or the potential of any of these things (at least based on your current psychological and moral course). Imagine the emptiness, the desperation, the unspeakable boredom you would feel. This will give you an inkling of what it is like for the irrational, range-of-the-moment person, who may feel he’s acting in his self-interest, but is actually making his life miserable both in the short-run and the long-run.

On top of these problems, he has alienated spouses, friends, children, and potential allies. He is never on a secure footing with anybody, even if initially the people he meets (not knowing him) give him the benefit of the doubt. They may not know, but he knows, that sooner or later they will be adversaries. Imagine the amount of effort it would take to carry on such evasion on such a massive scale, day-in and day-out. Think of the times you, yourself, might have repressed, evaded, or rationalized until you later quickly corrected yourself. By definition, the conventionally “selfish” person you mention is in this kind of mental state all of the time. By no stretch of the imagination can he be said to be living a self-serving life. In sacrificing others, through lying and so forth, he is not making his life better; he is simply trying to bring everyone else down with him, on his already sinking ship.

Mr. Kellard: Religion does teach certain rational virtues, such as honesty, which people practice and rightfully claim are morally and spiritually uplifting and which contribute to their success and happiness. In so far as this is true, how do the irrational basis for these virtues and values, i.e., faith in and obedience to God, and how do corrupt religious virtues and doctrines, such as humility and Original Sin, undercut and weaken the degree to which a person can possess happiness?

Dr. Hurd: Some religions do teach rational virtues, such as productivity and honesty; this is true. But they also teach selflessness and mystical faith: the exact opposite of what a rational and virtuous life requires. If an earnest religious person tries to practice both, he will inevitably develop some form of psychological conflict because a person cannot sustain such massive contradictions without consequences to his mental health.

Increasingly, today, people sense the contradiction within religious doctrines and opt to throw the whole thing out in favor of amoral subjectivism. Hence the well-known false alternative: to be selfless and “good” or to be selfish and “bad.” Few, if any, recognize that to be good is also, by definition, to be practical and to act in one’s objective, life-serving interest.

Is it any wonder so many suffer from psychological conflicts?

Mr. Kellard: Since religion has a virtual monopoly on moral values, it is obvious why many people who don’t opt for amoral subjectivism turn to religion for moral guidance. But what are the fundamental psychological reasons why certain people feel the need for a Superior Being that they believe lovingly protects them and commands their moral choices? What causes many people to generally feel life is empty without God?

Dr. Hurd: I think the fundamental reason some people yearn for a God is that they want someone else to do the work of judgment for them. Just as a subjectivist uses his feelings as an easy substitute for responsible, conscious, rational judgment, a religionist will use his faith in a particular God or God’s Commandments as a substitute for having to think. It is more than just laziness, however, which motivates such a person. It is a profound terror of having to accept responsibility for making judgments, for using reason, for using his own mind to ascertain reality, make a living, choose a marital partner, and all the decisions required throughout life. If he uses his own mind, then he must accept full responsibility for his choices, good ones and bad ones. A rational person welcomes this opportunity. But the religious person is terrified of this responsibility.

Of course, there are many other reasons why one is motivated to believe in God which can vary from individual to individual. For example, a person may believe in God out of fear of going to hell. Or simply because his parents did, and he sees no reason to question. Or because everybody else does, so how can it be wrong (social metaphysics). The possibilities are many. But I think that all of them will have one underlying motive in common: the fear of responsibility.

Mr. Kellard: I’ve heard religious people criticize cultists as being misguided since their faith lies in other men, whereas they have faith in an all-knowing Superior Being. In reality, what are the fundamental differences and correlations between people who belong to major religions, such as Christianity, Islam, Judaism, and those who belong to various cults?

Dr. Hurd: All share the same fundamental premises about the afterlife, belief in some kind of God, and mysticism in general. They merely differ in degree, despite the claims by mainstream religious authorities that there is a fundamental distinction between themselves and cults.

Psychologically, followers of cults versus more mainstream religions often differ in many of their motives. Followers of the cults generally have no interest in this life and want to be rid of the responsibility for rational thought and action as soon as possible. Many followers of mainstream religion, however, usually attach some degree of value to this life (sometimes a considerable degree, depending on the religion and the individual in question), and are attempting to use the better moral principles of religion to be productive and honest.

Unfortunately, as I said, the contradiction between these better principles, on the one hand, and the irrational belief in mystical entities and the alleged virtue of selflessness, on the other, has to lead to some degree of psychological conflict. Among the mainstream religious types, the psychological conflict may be tempered by the more rational aspects of their thinking and psychology. Among the cultist authority-worshippers, however, the bad premises have driven out the good ones entirely and the consequence—suicide—is the only “logical” choice left given their psychologies.

Michael J. Hurd, Daily Dose of Reason

Boasberg speaks – A partial victory for the DoJ, and at the same time a disaster for Ilhan Omar

Truly, we’re living in the end times. Inveterate Trump hater and TDS victim Judge James Boasberg on Tuesday released a decision in the Ilhan Omar Elmi case that, while not totally in favor of the Trump DoJ, was kinda sorta, in a vague sort of way, as balanced as we might expect from an American juror.

Boasberg was considering whether the DoJ should be forced to release the documentation on which the search warrant executed against Omar last October 12. The department wanted to keep this information secret for a number of good reasons, among them the fact that the investigation is not yet complete and there may be further actions involving those documents.

It now appears that Boasberg, who is accustomed to stretching the law like saltwater taffy at least partially agrees. In his decision, while he stated that some documents must be released, they can be redacted by DoJ lawyers, and that some important papers, in particular the original affidavit used to obtain the search warrants, need not be released at all. The catch – and there’s always a catch with Boasberg – is that the documents must be ready by this coming Friday.

This stands as a partial victory for the DoJ, and at the same time a disaster for Omar. It was widely feared that Boasberg had interjected himself in the case simply in the hopes of interfering with the administration. Now the department will be able to continue its investigation without fear of meddling, and with renewed hopes of locking the Somali cutie up and then chasing her back to Warlordistan.

Omar, with her lack of understanding exactly how the American system works, very likely believed she was home free after the midterms, that the day after the secret police would descend on the DoJand execute her tormentors before replacing them with friends of the donkey. Now, she’ll see a release of documents that will cause all kinds of uproar and speculation about what the redacted sections might contain, reviving the whole business at a very poor time. And just before the important Muslim holiday of Thanksgiving, too.

J.R. Dunn, American Thinker

The 85/15 Pattern: New Mathematical Analysis Raises Major Questions About the 2026 Election Results.

Editor’s note: This article has been substantially revised with additional testing and official election-process information.

A new mathematical analysis of the 2026 midterms has uncovered a pattern that election officials, data analysts, and voters should not casually wave away.

At the center of it is one number: 0.85.

The X account Truth Is Freedom found that Republican candidates repeatedly finished near 85% of President Donald Trump’s 2024 vote share. The account calls it the “15% Band” and argues that the consistency raises serious questions about the reported results.

Those questions deserve answers backed by data, audits, and ballot records—not slogans from either side.

The published math does not, by itself, prove that votes were switched or that any person, party, or voting system committed fraud. The pattern still deserves daylight.

It is a reason to put the full dataset under a microscope.

The original analysis compared 59 Senate and governor races with President Trump’s 2024 performance in the same states.

Its central formula was:

Republican 2026 share ≈ 0.85 × Trump’s 2024 share.

The account also expressed the Democratic side as Harris’s 2024 share plus 15% of Trump’s share.

THE 15% BAND

Look at this chart. 59 races. Senate and governor. States ordered from reddest to bluest in 2024.

The solid lines are 2024. The dashed lines are 2026. The shaded bands are what moved.

One formula fits all of it: Republican 2026 = 0.85 × Trump 2024 Democrat… pic.twitter.com/9cnJ5bAY54

— Truth Is Freedom (@TruthAnswersAll) November 6, 2026

The headline-grabbing formula is real. But there is also a mathematical catch that must be confronted honestly: the two equations are not independent findings.

In a two-party calculation, Harris’s share is the remainder after Trump’s share. Once the Republican result is defined as 0.85 times Trump’s share, the Democratic result is automatically the complement.

The second equation therefore cannot independently establish that votes moved from one side to the other. Anyone presenting it as separate confirmation is claiming more than the algebra supports.

The fixed starting point is legitimate. The Federal Election Commission’s official 2024 results compile the certified state totals that awarded President Trump 312 electoral votes and Kamala Harris 226.

The FEC report identifies state election offices as its source and preserves each state’s popular-vote totals, electoral votes, and candidate breakdown. That makes it a sound baseline for checking what the viral analysis actually calculated.

What those records cannot show is how an individual 2024 Trump voter behaved in 2026. Presidential and midterm electorates are different, turnout changes, voters skip lower-profile contests, candidates attract crossover support, and national political conditions can move many states at once.

Using the certified 2024 denominator is necessary, but it cannot solve those comparability problems. A valid causal claim still has to distinguish changed participation and voter preference from an altered count.

That means the 85/15 relationship describes the reported results. It does not yet identify the mechanism that produced them—and that unanswered question is exactly where serious scrutiny should begin.

An independent state-by-state reconstruction published by Lead Stories found that part of the pattern is real: a cluster of heavily Republican states landed close to the 0.85 estimate.

The reconstruction used reported 2024 presidential and 2026 Senate results, added Alaska, Arkansas, and Montana, and published its detailed comparison spreadsheet. That allows readers to inspect every state-level prediction directly rather than relying on the visual impression created by the original chart.

Here is where the viral claim meets a harder test: the same reconstruction found substantial misses in both directions. Across 32 Senate states, only eight were within one percentage point of the formula.

The deviations ranged from 6.5 points below the prediction in Rhode Island to 8.1 points above it in Maine.

The presentation also matters. The original chart used a compressed 20%-to-80% vertical scale across a very wide frame, making differences of several percentage points appear smaller than they are when the races are listed state by state.

Maine is especially important. Its 2026 Republican Senate candidate reportedly exceeded Trump’s own 2024 share, something a universal 15% reduction rule cannot produce consistently.

That variation does not erase the national Republican decline or make the broader pattern irrelevant. It does destroy the easy leap from “an average near 0.85” to “one fixed algorithm operated everywhere.”

One critic summarized the core problem directly: comparing aggregate vote shares across two elections does not track the movement of identified voters or ballots.

@gatewaypundit Trump sharing “THE 15% BAND” is not independent verification that votes were transferred. Your headline says “For Every 1,000 Trump Votes, 150 Shifted to Democrats.” The underlying chart measures vote shares across different elections—not the movements of 1,000…

— Brian Skellenger on all Platforms (@brianskellenger) November 8, 2026

Truth Is Freedom later expanded the analysis to 692 counties across six states where Republicans lost Senate races.

The account says a model using the 0.85 baseline, county Republican strength, and Hispanic population placed roughly 97% of those counties within five percentage points of its prediction.

If that 97% figure survives independent replication, it would demand a serious explanation. Right now, however, it cannot be independently verified from the public post alone.

The account has not released a complete reproducible package containing every input, the full county table, inclusion and exclusion rules, exact coefficients, code, revision history, and comparisons with ordinary election-swing models.

The five-point tolerance also matters. A model can classify many observations as “within range” when the permitted range is broad, especially after variables are selected with knowledge of the same data being explained.

A proper test needs a model fixed in advance and evaluated against data it was not built to fit. Otherwise, critics can reasonably argue that the model was tuned around the very results it purports to explain.

Truth Is Freedom has stood by the analysis and argues that critics are attacking the detector instead of explaining why it registered a signal.

Imagine this. ⁰You’re walking a beach with a metal detector. It starts beeping. You dig, and there it is: exactly what someone buried and hoped nobody would find.

Then a crowd shows up.⁰One guy says, “Your coil frequency is wrong.” Another says, “That model has a known…

— Truth Is Freedom (@TruthAnswersAll) November 18, 2026

Truth Is Freedom is right about one thing: sneering at the detector is not an answer.

Release the data. Test the signal.

Show where it holds, where it fails, and why.

As of November 18, several cited 2026 totals were still unofficial. The Ohio Secretary of State says bipartisan county boards must review outstanding ballots, resolve discrepancies, conduct the official canvass, and certify no later than 21 days after Election Day.

Ohio also requires post-election audits that hand-count selected paper ballots and compare them with electronically tabulated totals. Those records can move this debate beyond internet charts and into evidence that can actually confirm or rule out counting problems.

The state’s published process separates election-night reporting from the official canvass. Eligible provisional ballots and qualifying military and overseas ballots are added before certification, while county records are reviewed for discrepancies.

Ohio also sets an automatic statewide recount threshold of one-quarter of one percent. Together, the canvass, paper-ballot audit, and recount rules create specific evidence that can either reveal a tally problem or show that a viral statistical suspicion did not correspond to an actual counting error.

The Minnesota Secretary of State scheduled its state canvass for November 19. The state identified several contests within publicly funded recount margins, including a U.S. House race separated by 323 votes and a state Senate race separated by four.

Minnesota’s state canvassing board certifies state and federal results reported by local officials. The recount-eligible margins show why a preliminary election-night snapshot cannot be treated as the final dataset for a national mathematical claim.

The four-vote state Senate margin was just 0.04%, while the 323-vote U.S. House margin was approximately 0.1%. Those are concrete, contest-specific reasons for scrutiny, and Minnesota’s public process identifies the races and the legal mechanism for checking them.

This is where officials should welcome scrutiny instead of treating every question as an accusation. A recount can compare actual ballots with a reported result; a cross-election regression cannot do that by itself.

The Oregon Secretary of State says its results remain unofficial until December 10. Valid postmarked ballots could arrive through November 10, voters have through November 24 to resolve ballot challenges, and every county must complete a post-election audit before results become final.

Oregon publishes continuing ballot-return and unofficial-result updates while counties process eligible ballots. Its official page explicitly warns that those figures remain fluid until certification.

That warning is directly relevant to the 85/15 debate. A model calculated from an early snapshot can move as valid ballots are added, challenges are resolved, and county audits are completed.

Researchers therefore need to retain the exact timestamp and source file for every calculation, then rerun the model on Oregon’s certified results. Without that versioned trail, later claims that a prediction “fit” cannot be reproduced or fairly evaluated.

Those processes can change margins and model residuals. Any honest analysis must identify the precise data snapshot it used and rerun the calculations against certified totals.

The strongest conclusion the evidence supports today is that Republicans suffered a broad, measurable decline from Trump’s 2024 performance, and an average near 85% describes part of it.

Why did that pattern appear so broadly? How much came from turnout, candidate quality, national swing, demographics, or something else?

Those are major questions. The available evidence stops short of establishing a universal algorithm or proving that votes were transferred.

That evidentiary limit cannot become an excuse to shut down the inquiry.

Publish the full dataset. Publish the code.

Predeclare the model before testing it.

Run it against certified results and genuine holdout data. Force it to compete with ordinary national-swing, turnout, candidate-quality, and demographic models.

Then examine the records that could actually demonstrate manipulation: ballot reconciliations, voter files, chain-of-custody documents, machine logs, hand-count audits, and specific discrepancies tied to a county and contest.

Election integrity is too important for “trust us.” It is also too important to turn a statistical correlation into a solved crime before ballots, audits, and records establish one.

Demand the evidence. Demand the underlying data.

Demand that election officials answer legitimate questions with verifiable records.

Then follow the facts wherever they lead.

Isaac, 100% Fed Up